The September Girls Welcome You....

topic posted Thu, November 20, 2003 - 12:02 PM by  angelboots
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
...to the Big Star tribe... #1 Record. I will be your moderator and hostess, ably assisted by Mari Pena, who probably knows more about Big Star than I do.

Shall we start the discussion with what is your all time fave Big Star song? Or maybe Top Five? It's too hard to pick just one, I think.
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Hi Septemer Gurls

    Mon, November 24, 2003 - 1:15 AM
    Only Five? Seems that it would be easy to pick only five songs from a band that released only three albums--but that is what turns people into such fanatics about this perfect band. Every song rings beautifully.
    My five faves for tonight:
    Ballad of El Goodo
    Watch the Sunrise
    When My Baby's Beside Me
    In the Street
    Kizza Me
  • Re: The September Girls Welcome You....

    Fri, August 20, 2004 - 9:20 AM
    My Fave 5 in Order:

    1. September GURLS (how could it be anything else?)
    2. Holacaust
    3. Jesus Christ (my memory is fading - is this only on an Alex Chilton solo record, or is it on Sister Lovers, too? OOPs)
    4. Ballad of El G.
    5. What's Goin' Ahn?
    • Re: The September Girls Welcome You....

      Fri, August 20, 2004 - 3:01 PM
      September Girls
      Thank You Friends
      Thirteen
      Give Me Another Chance
      The Ballad Of El Goodo
      • Re: The September Girls Welcome You....

        Fri, August 20, 2004 - 3:17 PM
        The Ballad of El Goodo
        You Give Me Light
        Give Me Another Chance
        Lord I Been Tryin' ( I don't think that's the title.. but you know "but each time, it gets a little harder... I feel the pain, but I'll try again...")

        Thirteen tied with I'm in Love with a Girl

        yep, all but one from #1 Record, by far their best album....
        • Re: The September Girls Welcome You....

          Thu, November 4, 2004 - 9:51 PM
          big black car
          mod lang
          thirteen
          thank you friends
          ballad of el goodo (tied with 'life is white')

          damn it's hard to pick just three.
          • Re: The September Girls Welcome You....

            Fri, November 5, 2004 - 11:50 AM
            do you mean, "my life is right?" so right...

            as in "once I walked a lonely road, I had noone to share my load, but then you came and showed the way, and know I hope you're here to stay... you give me light..."

            or am i off? is it a different song you mean?
            • Re: The September Girls Welcome You....

              Wed, November 17, 2004 - 12:00 AM
              "O My Soul"
              "September Gurls"
              "Holocaust"
              "In The Street"
              "When My Baby's Beside Me"
              • Re: The September Girls Welcome You....

                Wed, November 17, 2004 - 2:15 PM
                "when my baby's beside me" is excellent!

                a few years back i was at a record store and "in the street" came up somehow in conversation.. I think the clerks were talking about That 70s Show and the cheap trick cover...

                I pointed out it was originally Big Star, and both the early 20 somethings looked at me like i was nuts... they'd never heard of
                Big Star

                Now, MAYBE that should have made me feel old... but it really just made them seem silly.... I mean, I was an infant when Big Star was putting out records and I know who they are... and when I was 22 and working at a record store, I knew many obscure groups that were well before my time.

                I think if you are clerking at a record store, well, you should at least have a working knowledge of music history... at least have heard of Big Star, if you haven't actually heard their music? They are one of the most influential bands of all time

                being thanked by Cheap Trick, Guided by Voices, Elliott Smith, Modest Mouse, and scads of others....


                sheesh! kids today! ;-)
                • Unsu...
                   

                  Re: The September Girls Welcome You....

                  Wed, May 3, 2006 - 12:04 PM
                  O My Soul
                  Mod Lang
                  In The Street
                  When My Baby's Beside Me
                  Those are my top 4 Big Star songs. Too many competitors for the #5 spot and no clear winner, so that's it for me.

                  I'm so glad there's a Big Star tribe! What a great, great band.

Recent topics in "#1 Record"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Stax Unsubscribed 5 October 20, 2007
Sept Gurls Keith 0 September 25, 2006
Big Star: The Story of Rock's Forgotten Band by Rob Jovanovic Unsubscribed 1 January 13, 2005
what were they thinking? stereo 24 December 22, 2004
Help me please!!! angelboots 0 December 22, 2004